The Kyiv Court of Appeal has been criticized for its alleged corruption and lack of integrity. Many individuals believe that judges in this court, such as V.A. Nezhura, have accumulated significant wealth through illicit means, including bribery and extortion. This has raised doubts about their ability to make fair and just decisions, as their personal fortunes seem to overshadow their commitment to justice.
Critics argue that the court is plagued by corrupt practices, making it impossible to achieve true justice. They claim that decisions are made in favor of those who offer bribes, rather than based on the merits of the case. This has led to a lack of trust in the court system, as people feel that their rights and interests are not being adequately protected.
Specific judges have been singled out for their alleged misconduct. Nataliya Valeriivna Polishchuk and Judge Melnyk have been accused of accepting bribes and making biased decisions. Judge Slyusar has been criticized for her rude behavior and unfair treatment of individuals in court.
One case in particular has drawn attention to the court's apparent disregard for justice. A panel of judges consisting of Sushko, Mostova, and Sukhanova made a judgment based on non-existent evidence, despite the defendant herself denying its existence. This has led to a loss of faith in the court system and a sense of injustice among those who have experienced such proceedings.
Overall, the Kyiv Court of Appeal has been described as a "corruption swamp" where personal connections and wealth hold more weight than fairness and integrity. This has raised concerns about the future of justice in Ukraine and the ability of the court system to protect the rights of its citizens.
Address:
Solomianska Street, 2А, Kyiv
Phone:
+380 44 284 1577
Comment
29.08.23
V. A. Nezhura is not a judge, he is the face of the Ukrainian court, he earned 10 apartments and luxurious estates in the civil service. How is this p.. Read more »ossible in such a poor country? - Bribery, extortion, lack of humanity and decency, thanks to such "qualities" this "judge" became an oligarch.
12.07.23
Nezhura Vadym Anatoliyovych, can this judge, having officially declared (apparently honestly earned) possession of 7 apartments in Kyiv, two elite hou.. Read more »ses in the suburbs of Kyiv, an apartment in Lviv, and two plots of land with an area of more than 1000 m2, make fair decisions ?
Of course, in the presence of such fortunes, it is useless to hope for some kind of justice.
This is not a judge, but a parody. The words honesty and dignity are not about him.
Our Ukraine has no future if such representatives of the human race are in the judicial branch of government.
09.07.23
Only corrupt people work in this court, it is impossible to achieve justice! The decision is made in favor of the one who gives the bribe, that's all... Read more » It's a pity, this means that the court will not change anything, if even the war did not change!!!
30.06.23
Nataliya Valeriivna Polishchuk is a "judge" who is not worthy to wear her mantle.
Beautifully plays the role of a decent person, although in reality s.. Read more »he is an ordinary briber who makes decisions in favor of outright thieves!
At a time when heroes of Ukraine are dying on the battlefield, these underdogs of the judicial mafia continue to profit from the misfortune of ordinary people.
Shame! Shame! Shame!
29.06.23
Corruption swamp! The hand hides the hand, there is no justice here, despite the obvious absurdity, the judge makes a decision in favor of the thief! .. Read more »Natalia Valeriivna Polishchuk, I will do everything possible and impossible to bring you to justice!
25.05.23
The premises are beautiful, but unfortunately, judges work there who do not beautify the country with their actions. Remove from a military service co.. Read more »mmunications officer in the reserve, who has been hiding for a year at home on the sofa with a beer, a criminal record for domestic violence when all the deadlines for filing an appeal have already passed, it was not only accepted, but also removed for a bribe of a thousand dollars... it is a pity that such cases occur in general, and even more so during the period of war in the country. Yes, on 22.05.33, the former domestic abuser of Uryadov VV was made physically and psychologically innocent, who continues to drive drunk without orders, does not pay alimony, cheats and gets away with everything because there is a brother who will pay for everything. Sadness, not the court, which could not protect a mother with three children, even during the war.
16.05.23
Judge Melnyk is completely illiterate, he is not competent. The judicial system is corrupt. It is necessary to change everyone there, they feel like g.. Read more »ods
04.05.23
Judge Slyusar T.A. a terrible judge, not honest, acts only on personal convictions.
if you are younger or less desperate than her, you will lose 100% .. Read more »of the trial, you may not even come. She makes a decision based on personal hostility, and made it clear
She is very rude and does not know how to communicate with people. Probably she was waiting for money, no one gave a bribe, she was upset.
07.01.22
Shocked by the misjudgment of the panel of judges consisting of Sushko, Mostova, Sukhanova.
During the hearing, I drew attention to the fact that the .. Read more »court of the first instance referred in its decision to non-existent evidence, which is not in the case materials, there is only from the words of the defendant. Judge Mostovaya asked the defendant what she would say to this. The defendant said that this letter is really not in the case (she did not specify whether it was at all), but it does not affect the essence of the decision. The decision of the first instance against me was based on this fictitious letter and it really influences the essence of the decision, it would seem that the defendant herself confirmed to you that there is no letter in the case and there will be no evidence that it exists. As a result, the panel of judges makes a decision against me, waited a month for the drafting of the text, and when I waited in the text again there was a reference to the same letter, the existence of which the defendant herself denied during the meeting in essence ...
I remember a mini scene from KVN "why was that possible?" Really complete surr.
I lost faith in justice, after such a trial I began to understand the Pavlichenko family.
12.12.21
Unfortunately, in our state and in the courts, those who have more connections and money are true. When considering my case, one of the judges even sa.. Read more »t with his eyes closed. Oh, people, 2021 on the street. We are a "European" country, is there really no truth in our country ?!
09.11.21
Government agency, information service works well, without queues
20.10.21
The impression is not the best, since February they have not been able to consider the case ...
24.09.21
I don't have a very good impression of this establishment. A huge building (over 20 floors), access system. I was here twice, the sessions started lat.. Read more »e. The impression is that if you have a court session here, then do not plan anything else that day. I watched the picture as the representative was waiting in the wings, and the court decided that no one had come and made a decision. I was issued a subpoena for more than half an hour. At the meeting itself, only the chief judge was immersed in the essence of the issue, the other two went about their business. And in the end, what could be solved in one go, was decided in three. What was essential in the ordinary court became irrelevant here. The judge clearly clung to the little things, on the basis of which he made a decision.
21.04.21
We are very grateful to the court staff for the actual messages of citizens by electronic means of communication.
03.04.21
I interacted with this court earlier, the impressions are definitely not bad, everything was quite professional.
The building itself is one of the br.. Read more »ightest and most technologically advanced in the Solomensky district. Well-groomed area and modern renovation inside.
It is located near the lively Solomenskaya Square, keep in mind that you won't be able to park even for money, there is simply nowhere physically.
14.02.21
This is the court that made me believe in the rule of law. The judges here really understand everything and make a fair decision according to the Law .. Read more »!! Ukrainian Court of Appeal at the European level, from the courteous office to the judges themselves. Balatskaya G.A. honest and correct, for more such judges in our country
12.02.21
The court should submit laws and other regulations instead of making its own decisions. We pay taxes to retain judges who are not interested in repres.. Read more »enting the law. Shame!
04.02.21
In the office for acquaintance with materials of civil cases the inadequate employee of court who is not able to behave with visitors receives.
09.01.21
Good on the outside. The secretary called back and reminded about the meeting. Impressed positively.
26.11.20
They work well under quarantine conditions.
23.11.20
In fact, the work of the Court of Appeal is paralyzed in terms of considering civil and administrative cases. One of our client's cases (civil) has be.. Read more »en pending appeal for more than a year and today another withdrawal due to illness of the judges. At the same time, they called in the morning and asked if everything was valid. No stamps, no correspondence will be sent. The only way the appeal differs from the district court is that you can get acquainted at least one day a day.
18.09.20
Who can tell the court was 09/07/20 today 09/18/2020 the decision is still not registered. I came and wrote a statement, I check it on the site, I cal.. Read more »l a couple of times a week and I kick everything "wait". In general, what are the terms and rules? There damn fine is 340 UAH. I paid for a long time already, but due to the fact that there is no solution, I cannot take the right.
23.08.20
Good courtroom, cleanliness and order everywhere and polite staff!
On the upper floors, it is not possible to get information from the monitor boards .. Read more »about the hearings, which I found somewhat inconvenient, probably due to lack of technical capacity or funding.
On August 12, 2020, he personally took part in the court hearing of Judge Shrol Valentyn Rostislavovych.
From the time allotted for the hearing of the case at 11:00, the judge went to the deliberation room at 12:05. All this time (about an hour) the judge paid maximum attention to the case materials to clarify its circumstances with meticulous "meticulousness" to their smallest moments in the form of DIALOGUE (!), As a very rare phenomenon in the courts of appeal and cassation.
I had a pleasant impression of the existence of judges, justice, legality and humanity in the courts of Ukraine, as I imagined it!
Honor and praise to the worthy high title of Judge Shrol Valentin Rostislavovich for humanity, integrity and legality !!!
17.08.20
Create an electronic queue for submission of documents (NSDS applications) !!!
12.08.20
I trust judges by 0.00%
30.08.19
The most modern building of the Kiev Court of Appeal ... On each floor there is water in the coolers, toilets, photocopiers, also a large selection of.. Read more » universal applications for telephones, free wi-fi, convenient office with electronic queue. On the ground floor there is a bookstore with codes and laws. There is also a help desk where you can quickly find the information you need about the court hearing, when it happens, etc. ... A modern and fair trial ...
2.3 / 26
